The Christmas Classic

A Christmas Carol, Charles Dickens

"Oh, I love A Christmas Carol! Which is your favorite movie of the story?" I'd have to say "Mr. Magoo." But my favorite version is still the book. For a small book it is filled with the most beautiful imagery, especially Dickens' description of the marketplace at Christmastime. Scrooge's transformation is more gradually done compared to how it's portrayed in most of the films and seems more realistic. There's also a charming scene at nephew Fred's house where they play the traditional Christmas games like blindman's buff.

This year I read this little version, which I found in Five Below, and which is an exact reproduction (down to size) of the first edition (except the four hand-colored illustrations aren't hand-colored anymore). I also have the wonderful Candlewick Press edition as well as the annotated edition.

See and love any movie version you can! But do read the book!

Old-Fashioned Christmases

Old Christmas, Washington Irving
These are the five Christmas chapters from Irving's famous Sketchbook of Geoffrey Crayon (which also includes the short stories "Rip Van Winkle" and "The Legend of Sleepy Hollow"). "Crayon" takes a trip to England during the Christmas season and runs into an old friend on the way home to the family country house. He spends Christmas with them and finds that his friend's father celebrates in the old medieval style. Nostalgia infused with Irving's sly humor about dad's real motive.

The Little Book of the Nativity, Dominique Foufelle
This is a cute little mini volume filled with minute print and old-fashioned postcards and missal cards that tell the story of the Nativity from the Annunciation through the the visit of the Magi, and the representations of it that we use today. Several pages talk about "santons," the special figures that the French use in their crechè scenes, portraying typical French villagers like the blind man and the Romany couple. The vintage chromolithographs are mostly French with a few German representations tossed in.

 

Bring Hankies

The Eight Heartbreaks of Hanukkah, Jean Meltzer

This book made me cry, and not just at the end.

Evelyn Schwartz has one goal in life: to be the best TV producer. To achieve that, she will work through punishing migraines, always driven to get ahead. As she is buckling down to direct a live television performance of A Christmas Carol, starring a famous pop star/actor in the Scrooge role, her migraines return with a vengeance, but now they seem to contain hallucinations: the ghost of her late mentor appears, urging her to live more of her life rather than sacrificing it all for her career. In order to learn what's important, she's going to be haunted by eight Hanukkah spirits.

This sounds like it might be silly, but it truly isn't. One of the casualties of Evelyn's career resolutions was her marriage to Daniel, a lifelong friend and supporter who willingly gave up his own career goals to support her. But two years earlier, their marriage ended in divorce after Daniel walked out on her.

Or did he? Because as the spirits show, Evelyn isn't remembering things quite as they were. But now Daniel is the temporary doctor at her production studio and he's worried about her sudden fainting spells and talking about hallucinations. He's also still in love with her (and her with him, despite his leaving).

Despite the spirits occasionally being funny, this is a tearjerker. And no, Evelyn is not berated for her ambition. The pop star actor is really weird; reminds me of the dude in the "Icarus" episode of Law & Order: Criminal Intent, only he truly can act.

Inspirational Reads

The Joys of Christmas 2013 - Guideposts
Ideals Christmas 2024
Ideals Christmas 2025

I've been buying Ideals for years now, once they began using beautiful photographs. The photos will always give me a Christmas "mood." Last year I hadn't the opportunity to read the issue, so I read this and last year's, and the Guideposts magazine, in one fell swoop.

I did like the inclusion of more Christmas stories in the Guideposts issue. Several of them were very nostalgic and touching, especially the Vietnam story—all the military stories were heart-tugging. Also was happy to see an Apollo 8 story!

Ideals, of course, is as always a feast of lovely images. The sunset image on page 38 of the 2025 issue is particularly beautiful.

A Historic Christmas

One Christmas in Washington, David Bercuson and Holger Herwig

This isn't particularly a "Christmas book," but it takes place mostly during December and the end of the Christmas season in January. It's the story of Winston Churchill's historic visit to Washington, DC in December 1941 in order to make a more firm alliance with the United States in the war against Nazism.

For two years, Great Britain had "gone it alone," trying to hold on as the German army marched across Europe, swallowing Belgium, the Netherlands, Czechoslovakia, Austria, and more, and finally France. The next step, the British knew, would be the invasion of the British Isles. So far Franklin Delano Roosevelt had managed to persuade a war-wary Congress (all of them having remembered "the Great War" of 1914-1917) to at least approve his "Lend-Lease" program so that the British would have arms to fight with. But no way, the American public vowed, would we get drawn into another European war.

Pearl Harbor changed everything, especially when Adolf Hitler allied himself with the Empire of Japan. This is the story of the buildup to the event, of Churchill's clandestine visit to the United States and his stirring Christmas Eve message, and the eventual results.

If you are a history buff, especially one with an interest in World War II, this volume is recommended.

Mystery/Romance in a British Country House

The Most Wonderful Crime of the Year, Ally Carter

I almost passed this book up because I hated the cover. Good thing I reconsidered, because this was really enjoyable.

Maggie Chase writes successful cozy mysteries. Ethan Wyatt writes hi-tech thrillers. Their writings certainly don't vibe, and neither do they. Maggie also hates Christmas because everything bad in her life that's happened to her has happened around Christmas, like her parents dying, finding out her husband was sleeping with her best friend, "little" things like that. Ethan's bigger than life and for some reason he keeps calling her "Marcie." So she's really excited when she's invited to a real English house party—yes, in England!—at the home of Eleanor Ashley, queen of the murder mystery genre (think Agatha Christie).

Except that Ethan is also an invited guest. Well, she'll put up with him to spend Christmas with Eleanor Ashley, not to mention an entire houseful of guests who don't seem to like Eleanor very much and resent the fact that these two Americans are crashing their party.

And then Eleanor vanishes. Everyone but Maggie thinks something bad has happened, but Maggie's sure this is a test. Eleanor wants to quit writing and retire, and this mystery is a way of working out her successor. The person who solves it will take over her series.

But if that's true, why is someone trying to kill her? And why is Ethan not the awful guy she thought he was?

There's a couple of blips in this: at one point Maggie gets a head injury and Ethan's all in a hurry to get her to a doctor, fearing a concussion, and next they're taking refuge from a snowstorm in a cottage and neither of them seem very worried at all. But most of all this was great fun.
.

Comfort Read #3

The Tuckers: The Cottage Holiday, Jo Mendel

I've had this book since I was about ten years old, and I read it every Christmas. It was part of a series that began with The Wonderful House, about the Tucker family (dad, stay-at-home but active mom, five kids, a big furry dog, and a black cat) moving to a big house in the fictional town of Yorkville from a city apartment.

The older, active kids (Tina, Terry, and Merry) get the lion's share of the other books, but this is the first of the two that center around Penny. Penny, age 7, is susceptible to colds, stays home sick a lot, and is starting to resent it. She wants to have adventures like her older siblings. Even her little brother Tom is stronger than she is. As the story opens, she wishes the family could spend Christmas at their lake house, where they could play in the snow and skate and romp to their hearts' content. To her surprise, her doctor says that if she takes precautions, she's healthy enough to go. And so they decamp to the lake, where they truly have an adventurous Christmas, contending with an abandoned baby, a cougar that's killing local livestock, and Penny's search for her true self.

It's told in simple vocabulary, but Christmas at Lake Annabelle sounds like a blast; I would have loved to have spent it with the Tuckers. And Penny also gets a surprise about herself. "Very kringly," as Betty Roberts of Remember WENN might say.
.

History--Yes. Commentary--No.

The Dead of Winter, Sarah Clegg

Christmas in the past wasn't all Santa Claus bringing gifts, red-nosed reindeer, and Frosty the snowman (who isn't even a Christmas thing, originally). Christmas in the past was a time of evil spirits slipping through the thin veil that separates the real and spiritual world, ghost stories, and companions of "Santa" (St. Nicholas) who threatened to punish naughty children by eating them, opening up their stomachs, or putting them into a bag and taking them to be punished.

Clegg takes trips to Europe to investigate locations that still play up these Christmas visitors, including Wales to follow a Mari Lywd parade and Sweden to investigate Santa Lucia and the Netherlands to see St. Nicholas and Zwarte Piet, and of course the infamous Krampus. She also visits Carnival in Venice, because many Christmas customs that were discarded once people stopped celebrating the 12 Days of Christmas migrated to Carnival. She gives us her point of view of these celebrations, but also includes an endless litany of how the past was racist, sexist, and every other kind of bad "ist." It was very off-putting to have the narrative interrupted so many times with this "but!" commentary. It would have been best to deal with it once, in a foreward, and stop with the lecturing. I would have appreciated a deeper delving into the customs rather than just her POV of them without the constant criticism of the past.
.

If The Ghost and Mrs. Muir Ended Differently

Good Spirits, B.K. Borison

I ugly cried at the end of this.

For years, Nolan Callahan, formerly a 19th century Irish fisherman who drowned during a storm, has been one of a cadre of "Ghosts of Christmas Past." They visit people who have, like Ebenezer Scrooge, done something bad in their past and who need to atone for it. It adds a little interest to his colorless afterlife. But then he's assigned to Harriet York, a free-spirited, mouthy young woman who runs an antique store (having displeased her rigid lawyer family for years with her career choice). He can't see what on earth Harriet has to atone for; indeed, after several visits to her past, he starts to feel that several of the people in her life need to atone to her!

In return, Harriet is suddenly making Nolan do things he hasn't been able to do since his death: taste, smell, feel. He has no idea what's going on, especially when his trips with Harriet into what's supposed to be her past turn out to be excursions into his past.

I really liked Harriet and hated her simply awful family, trying to press her into a mold she simply didn't fit into. Nolan is also a great character, especially in his interactions with his supervisor, the enigmatic Isabella. The antique store and its contents are almost another character in themselves; I'd live there!

Especially for fans of the television series of The Ghost and Mrs. Muir, this is a touching paranormal read.

Comfort Read #2

Sleigh Bells for Windy Foot, Frances Frost

This one goes way back for me, probably 1965-1966 from the Stadium School library, second in a four-book series about the Clark family living on their small farm in post-war Vermont. It's the story of Toby Clark, the eldest of three children, and his adventures with his family and his pony Windy Foot, given to him for his 12th birthday in the opening novel, Windy Foot at the County Fair.

In that story, Toby met Tish Burnham, daughter of widower Jerry Burnham, an owner of fine race horses. Tish rides her pony in the pony race at the county fair, which Toby wins, but they become fast friends. In this book the Clarks prepare for a Christmas visit from Tish and her dad.

It floors me every time I read this book how much work the Clark family does each day, but they still have time to go to carol sings and Christmas shopping, and have a Christmas party. I get tired just from Toby's daily schedule having to help milk the cows, chopping wood for his mother's stove, and four million other farm chores, plus in this story he cuts down a larger two-passenger sleigh so he can take Tish on a sleigh ride with Windy Foot! And later he has to guard the house against a bear that is killing farm livestock. And he and his sister Betsy still have time to go into the woods to gather Christmas greens, and play with rhyming little brother Johnny (who, I admit, can get a little annoying!).

This is one of those warm, old-fashioned stories you read with a cup of cocoa in an armchair. Nostalgia by the mile. Comfort. Home. Family.

The History of St. Nicholas and How He Became Santa...Maybe

Santa Claus Worldwide, Tom A. Jerman

It's simple, right? Way back when the United States was just a collection of colonies, the Dutch brought a gift giver named "St. Nicholas" our way. They called him "Sinter Klaus." Years, a poem by Clement C. Moore and an artist named Thomas Nast formed him into the "Santa Claus" we know today. And around the world there are related gift givers like "Father Christmas" (the "English Santa") and "Pere Noël," and a few offbeat ones, like Santa Lucia and La Befana.

Well, hold on, because a lot of the "St. Nicholas brought over by the Dutch in New Amsterdam [today's New York City] lore" was made up by Washington Irving. And there was a poem that proceeded Moore's Visit from St. Nicholas called "Old Sancte Claus" that featured Santa being pulled by...yes, reindeer. And Thomas Nast...

Jerman tries to make sense of all this and all the other "Santa" antecedents, including the grimy companions of St. Nicholas, like Krampus, Pere Fouttard, Pelznichol, Belsnickel, etc. whom he believes are the real ancestors of today's Santa Claus, not St. Nicholas. And along the way we learn more about some of those odd gift givers and Christmas creatures, like the Yule Cat who will attack you if you're not wearing new clothes on Christmas (is this where the socks and underwear gifts come from), the downright creepy Yule Lads with their cringe names like "pot-licker," Frau Perchta who opens up the stomachs of naughty children and stuffs rocks or straw inside them, or more.

Very detailed, but absolutely fascinating, with a detailed bibliography.
.

Inept Detective Vs. Mysterious Small Town

Murder at Holly House, Denzil Meyrick

Everyone seems to have loved this book; I see it on bestseller lists. I bought it because, well, hey, period murder mystery (1952) in England, in a country house. Even the protagonist, a slightly inept police inspector (Frank Grasby) seemed intriguing. Plus it took place at Christmas. In Yorkshire.

Sorry, I was less than enchanted. After awhile, Frank's ineptness just got tiring, Christmas wasn't acknowledged much at all, and Our Hero just got into more and more absurd situations. The mystery is overshadowed by another sinister thing going on in the village.

The female protagonist turns out to be too good to be true, but deathly dull at the same time, and, after reading it, I don't remember many of the supporting characters. By the last half I just wanted to know if they caught the bad guys and who the dude stuffed up the chimney was—an anticlimactic revelation, incidentally—and get it over with.

I doubt if I would have ever read another Frank Grasby mystery. Sadly, the author passed away just as this was published. I'm sad to hear that, but not about not being tempted to read another story about the character.
.

The Final Volume and One of the Best

A Wiltshire Christmas, compiled by John Chandler

I found the first one of these Sutton Christmas anthologies (A Worcestershire Christmas, if you care) at a library book sale several years back, and another at a library sale a couple of years later. Since then I've been collecting and reading them all; they contain short excerpts of Christmas/Christmastide passages from various British novels, memoirs, and poetry books, with the action taking place in the shire or historical era denoted in the title.

This is the final volume of the regional ones I've collected, and happily, it's one of my favorites. Several of the volumes seemed to just repeat the same old "George and the Dragon" mummers play over and over, and the entries were blah. This one contains a variety of memories from various decades, including the story of evacuees from London during World War II, accounts of a devastating pre-Christmas storm in 1859 and flooding in January of 1915, Christmas carols unique to the region, an odd version of "George and the Dragon" with a Duke and Duchess and a Captain Curly, an account of mummers and another of waits, and even the sweet story "Mog" about a little boy who wants a cat for Christmas, but his dad is dead set against it...until...

So. I'm done! I have the whole set!

Will Elk Ridge Lose Its Magic?

A Spell for Midwinter's Heart, Morgan Lockhart
Thank goodness! A romantic novel with adults who act like adults!

Years earlier, Rowan Midwinter desperately wanted to save her grandmother's home from developers. Her hometown, Elk Ridge in the Rockies, is a haven for many magic users who follow pagan traditions, and she was to help cast a spell to save it. She failed and quit using magic that day. She won't even use it to help persuade people to invest into a worthy solar power franchise. But she promised her mother to come home for Yule; on her path home, she re-encounters her old school rival Gaven McCreery, whose father is now hell-bent on selling out the whole town of Elk Ridge to some big city developers. And it may happen, because Elk Ridge makes its biggest money at their winter festival at Yule—and this year's may be a bust because there's no snow.

The two storylines develop in parallel: Rowan and Gavin's rediscovery of each other as well as Rowan and her friends and family trying to keep the specter, of cookie-cutter commercial development from taking over Elk Ridge and its unique inhabitants. Rowan must come to terms with what she saw as her initial failure that just let her into a downward spiral in which she sees failure as her only future, and learn to love herself as Gavin also begins to love her, and she him.

This book includes a great supporting cast, including Rowan's brother, mother, and father, and her best friend, Zaide, and Zaide's lover Naomie. I really enjoyed this one!

Monster "Mash" at Christmas

Scary Book of Christmas Lore: Forget About Jingle Bells & Jolly Old Saint Nick, Tim Rayborn

Christmas! Sweet Santa and his reindeer deliver presents! Back at the North Pole, Mrs. Claus makes cocoa for the elves! It's all sweetness and light at Christmas...

Well, maybe today, but in the past, did you know that the "Santa" figure sometimes was accompanied by a companion who punished naughty children, some by eating them, some by stuffing them in a bag. Not to mention, there's a Yule cat and a Yule goat wandering about, contemplating mayhem. In Greece and Turkey, there are the Kallikantzaroi, evil goblins who wander the countryside during the Twelve Days of Christmas. Additionally, there's Frau Perchta, who slits the bellies of naughty children and makes straw people of them. And then there's the infamous Krampus...

If you want a different Christmas read, this roster of Christmas monsters may be up your alley. Short entries for each Christmas ghoul make it perfect days-before-Christmas reading.

Poetry and More

A West Country Christmas, edited by Chris Smith

This is another of Alan Sutton publishing's "Christmas Anthologies," which contain short excerpts of Christmas/Christmastide passages from various British novels, memoirs, and poetry books, with the action taking place in the shire or historical era denoted in the title.

Covering England's "West Country" (Cornwall and Somerset), known for their oft-parodied "z" accents, this particular volume is almost half-filled with poetry from Samuel Taylor Coleridge, Robert Herrick, Christina Rossetti, Charles Kingsley, and others. Contributors of prose include Conan Doyle with an excerpt from Hound of the Baskervilles (although it really had nothing to do with Christmas), Agatha Christie (Poirot celebrates the holidays), Daphne DuMaurier, Blackmore's Lorna Doone, and Thomas Hardy.

The Glastonbury Thorn, the legendary tree that supposedly blooms every year on "the real Christmas" (by the Julian calendar, now January 7), has its own chapter, as does the West Country tradition of mumming. Other memoirs tell of old-fashioned Christmases with simple toys and reveling, there is—of course—a ghost story or two, there's a long chapter with Christmas excerpts from West Country newspapers, and even the amazing story of a shepherd who saves 66 sheep from freezing on a snowy night by carrying them back two by two to a barn. Old engravings, photographs, and advertisements complete this interesting volume.

Everything That's Christmas: Memoirs, Memories, and Ghosts!

A Warwickshire Christmas, edited by David Green
This is another in Alan Sutton publishing's line of Christmas books, either from English shires (their equivalent of a county) or during a certain time or literary period. Having picked up one (Worcestershire Christmas) at a book sale, I've collected one or two at the time when I can find them inexpensively. I've collected all the regional ones now, and this is the third from the last.

The contents of these books are kind of a coin toss. Sometimes it's obvious that there aren't a lot of Christmas writings from the particular shire and they have tossed in winter observances like the weather or references to cold weather or they've included the "St. George and the Dragon" play in its entirety. This volume, however is crammed with memoirs of holiday celebrations from the POV from all walks in life, from Daisy England, a poor child whose father left the family and who eventually ended up in the workhouse, to the Christmases celebrated by Frances, Countess of Warwick. Three contributions are from Ursula Bloom, a prolific writer of 560 books, from childhood memories to ghost stories she was told by a family servant. Vivian Bird recalls a chill, cheerless Christmas in which he was serving in the Army during the Second World War. There are excerpts from Silas Marner, another George Eliot novel Brother Jacob, and two excerpts from Washington Irving's Old Christmas (a part of The Sketchbook of Geoffrey Crayon), as well as a short account of Christmas at Aston Hall, the prototype for Irving's Bracebridge Hall. There are accounts of meager Christmases in poor homes and bountiful Yuletides at manor homes, and even a fascinating article talking about stagecoaches—you are used to seeing stagecoaches in Western movies with passengers riding inside and the driver and the person "riding shotgun" on the outside, but, on British stagecoaches at least, passengers who paid less actually rode outside.

Plus there are illustrations and many many nostalgic photos of snowy lanes and old-fashioned sights like poultry shops and horse-drawn vehicles. One of the best Sutton Christmas anthologies!

Not Nostalgic Enough

Christmas TV Memories: Nostalgic Holiday Favorites of the Small Screen, Herbie J. Pilato
I've been waiting on this book since I saw it promoted and learned that it had a chapter about The House Without a Christmas Tree, which is one of my very favorites, if not favorite (it changes by year) Christmas movie ever (it alternates with The Homecoming). Now that I've read it, I loved the House chapter and about half of the rest of the book.

I found the rest...kind of annoying. First, the book seems to spend an inordinate amount of time talking about television variety Christmas specials. I realize they're a rara avis these days, and certainly the biggest of them, hosted by Bob Hope, Perry Como, Bing Crosby, Andy Williams, etc., were fabulous and bear examining; I loved it a few years back when MEtv showed a bunch of these gems, including Perry Como's Early American Christmas and Christmas in Paris. It's the one- or two-time specials that seemed out of place, and after the first few chapters they seem all jumbled together.

The remainder of the chapters address animated specials, Christmas television films, and Christmas episodes of series favorites. The quality wavers between detailed examinations of one item (like The House Without a Christmas Tree) to chapters like the one about The Simpsons which basically just lists all the Simpsons Christmas episodes. It would have been better to say there were 21 episodes and mention the first and a couple of notable ones.

Pilato also says, naturally, there wasn't time in 300 pages to mention every Christmas special and every Christmas episode of every series—I was particularly disappointed by the complete omission of all eight Lassie Christmas episodes—yet there is plenty of time, apparently, to mention Thanksgiving episodes and New Year's episodes!—not to mention numerous asides about what star was married to another star who went on to produce fill-in-the-blank famous movie with no connection to Christmas. Not only that, but the subtitle is "nostalgic holiday favorites." Everyone's nostalgic about Rudolph and Frosty and other 60s and 70s animated shows and episodes; who the dickens is nostalgic about some forgettable episode of Reba that's aired ten years ago?

Particularly irritating was the chapter about The Homecoming: A Christmas Story, in which several pages were wasted talking about the dreadful remake they did a couple of years ago which I turned off in disgust after ten minutes when Jason started berating John-Boy about his stupidity in wanting to be a writer! The set decoration looked like it came out of an issue of "Country Living" and makes the Walton family look prosperous instead of just getting by. Ugh! And the chapter about The Gathering devotes two of the four pages to another film the director did called Peege. Huh?

Pilato even gets part of the plot of the memorable episode of That Girl called "Christmas and the Hard Luck Kid" incorrect: Tommy, the little boy Ann Marie is keeping company at Christmas, isn't Jewish; his friend whom he eventually spends Christmas Day with is the one who's Jewish.

I'm keeping this because of The House Without a Christmas Tree chapter, but, really, I wish I'd found it at the library booksale instead of forking over $20+ dollars on it.

Mysteries and Ghosts Make a Good Combination

Mystery for Christmas, edited by Richard Dalby
This is a collection of mystery stories...surprise...set around Christmas, with most of them having a supernatural twist. It begins with the ultimate in ghost story authors, Charles Dickens himself, with "The Black Veil." Several other classic authors are represented, including Thomas Hardy. Some of the stories feature murder, but there are other situations including a kidnapped child, a reluctant church attendee, a mysterious photograph, sudden deaths at a house party, even an unusual meal eaten in Persia and the adventures of a ghost, not to mention a locked-room mystery.

I loved almost every one of these stories; I think my least favorite was the one by Keating. Even the Sherlock Holmes pastiche and the story that's a takeoff on M.R. James and King's College.

There are several of these collections done by Dalby, including Ghosts for Christmas, which I've previously reviewed.

A Christmas at the Lake

The Tuckers: The Cottage Holiday, Jo Mendel
This is the Christmas entry in Mendel's Tuckers series, about a family of five children, stay-at-home-mom, and a dad who runs a variety store with his father. The stories are usually simple, but sometimes humorous, sometimes dramatic situations around family life.

Cottage Holiday revolves around seven-year-old Penny, who's the often-sick member of the family, who's tired of being pampered and longs to discover what she's good at like her talented brothers and sisters. She wishes the whole family could spend Christmas at the family's summer cottage on the lake—and what a surprise to discover that her doctor says she is well enough to go!

The rest of the story involves the kids' adventures on the lake, which includes hiking, hunting a lost calf with some young friends who live on a nearby farm, finding an abandoned baby, and coping with the fact that a renegade cougar is prowling the area.

The main charm of this story is nostalgia: the kids sometimes quarrel, but they love each other as well; their simple adventures encompass positive values without being preachy. This story is particularly charming because Penny, who's usually a background character, comes into her own here. Her baby steps into finding herself gives it an introspective undercurrent that the other books don't have.